Saturday, September 10, 2011

The 9/11 memorial that disappears after tomorrow

 click images for larger view.  photograph courtesy of The Art Institute of Chicago
Sectarianism, bigotry, and its horrible descendant, fanaticism, have long possessed this beautiful earth. They have filled the earth with violence, drenched it often and often with human blood, destroyed civilization and sent whole nations to despair. Had it not been for these horrible demons, human society would be far more advanced than it is now. But their time is come; and I fervently hope that the bell that tolled this morning in honor of this convention may be the death-knell of all fanaticism, of all persecutions with the sword or with the pen, and of all uncharitable feelings between persons wending their way to the same goal - Swami Vivekananda, Chicago, September 11, 1893
Tomorrow is the 10th anniversary of the 9/11, when the twin towers of New York's World Trade Center were destroyed after being hit by jet airplanes hijacked the terrorists.  The day will be filled with solemn observances worldwide, at the new Michael Arad memorial at Ground Zero, and at other memorials to the tragedy in other locations.

One of the most eloquent memorials to 9/11, however, will disappear after tomorrow.  Jitish Kallat's Public Notice 3, on the great stair of the Art Institute of Chicago, goes, not forward from 9/11,but  back over a century, to September 11, 1893, when Swami Vivekananda addressed the Parliament of the World's Religions, held in conjunction with the World's Columbian Exposition, in an auditorium constructed in the Art Institute building, in a space rebuilt into galleries long ago.

While the memorials to 9/11 are about loss, the constructions arising out of 9/11 are mostly about fear.  At Ground Zero, a 1776-foot-tall "Freedom Tower" continues to rise whose base is a 186-foot-tall, windowless concrete bunker, ostensibly to thwart would-be future terrorists by withstanding the strongest truck bomb.  SOM architect David Childs' proposal to distract onlookers from the bunker's oppressive message was to cover it with mirrors, 2,000 prismatic glass panels, like a gigantic disco ball, meaningless glitter covering an iron fist.  But when the glass broke and bowed during the initial installation earlier this year, the concept was abandoned.  And while billions is being spent to make Freedom Tower a fortress impregnable to terrorists, right next door Maki and Associates 72-story Four World Trade Center offers up a completely open, glassed-in entrance floor.  Apparently, the assumption is that terrorists would simply overlook such tempting, more vulnerable targets as Four World Trade or the bird-like Santiago Calatrava transit center nearby.

What Freedom Tower memorializes is not American resolve but paranoia and crippling fear.  Largely, the architectural responses to 9/11 have been less realistic responses than an often irrational pandering to that fear.  Visitors to the Capitol Visitor in Washington are now channeled like rats through a $600 million underground bunker that looks like it was designed by Albert Speer.  The Trib's Blair Kamin wrote this week on how the same mindset has blighted such areas as Union Station, Mies' Federal Center and Pei Cobb's Hyatt Center on Wacker.  At the height of post 9/11 trauma, Architect Carol Ross Barney proved that security can be addressed with exceptional humane design in her for the 2004 federal building that replaced the Alfred P. Murrah building destroyed by a domestic terrorist truck bomb in 1995 that killed 168 people.  Would that more had followed her example.

Instead we get bunkers and bollards, metal detectors and strip searching grandmothers.  And words.  A torrent of words pouring through the media this week on the 10th anniversary of 9/11.  Including, I'm afraid, these of my own.
None, however, will be more powerful that those of Kallat's Public Notice 3 at the Art Institute.  Kallat has covered the risers of the museum's great stair with strips of LED's, alternating in the colors of Homeland Security's threat coding system, bearing the words of Swami Vivekananda's 1893 speech.  Like Childs' prism glass, those words shine brightly.  Which path is more likely to lead us to a happier, more secure future? 

Public Notice 3 is scheduled to be taken down after tomorrow, Sunday, September 11th.  Read our original story about the artwork, and the 1893 Parliament of Religions in Chicago's Art Institute, here.

Thursday, September 08, 2011

from Parking Garage to Museum of Broadcast Communications in just Eight Easy Lessons Years

To put it in perspective, construction on the 1161-foot-tall Trump Tower was started about the same time, and they managed to finish it over two years ago. The new home for the Museum of Broadcast Communications hasn't been so lucky.  This is what they started out with, way back in 2005 . . .
click images for larger view
. . . a rather forlorn-looking parking garage at the corner of Kinzie and State, which within a year or so, was supposed to be transformed into this . . .
. . . a sparkling, 70,000 square-foot, $21 million facility designed by Eckenhoff Saunders Architects in partnership with sustainable design architect Helen Kessler.  And for a while, things went swimmingly.  The steel frame for the new State Street facade went up later that year . . .
. . . and the following March, the glazing was mounted into the frame.  (See more pictures of this here.)
Then, a funny thing happened on the way to the Museum, in the person of  loon Illinois governor Rod Blagojevich promising $6 million for the the project, and then never coming through with the money. Fund-raising dried up.  So, shortly after the curtain wall went up, construction stopped, and the structure was left as an unfinished hulk.
At one point, the contractor, Pepper Construction, claimed there were $4.5 million in unpaid bills.  Then in 2010, Illinois governor Pat Quinn came through with the originally promised $6 million, and construction resumed.
  
In June of this year, there was a "Sneak Preview" of the new building, complete with a red carpet entrance of  Bozo and Svengoolie, and the hope is now to get the thing opened in time for the Museum's 25th anniversary next year.  We'll see.  But even now, especially on the Kinzie street side, it's a fairly handsome transformation.
 

Tuesday, September 06, 2011

Mies on LSD (a rare trip), John Vinci on Hyde Park, plus Hump Hair Pin and yet another Bertrand Goldberg exhibition - still more for September

So we just put up the September Calendar of Chicago Architectural Events and we're already adding items.  On Tuesday, the 13th, John Vinci will discuss the transformation of a cable car waiting room into the home of the Hyde Park Historical Society, while, on Tuesday, September 20th, the Mies van der Rohe Society will be offering a rare tour, including a wine reception at the home of Don Powell, of the 860-880 Lake Shore Drive Apartments.  Tickets aren't cheap, but proceeds go towards restoration of The God Box, the Mies van der Rohe designed Carr Memorial Chapel on the IIT campus.

We've also gotten more information on Preservation Chicago's annual benefit, Friday, September 23rd,  at the Logan Square Arts Center, in the 1930 Art Deco building originally designed for the Hump Hair Pin Manufacturing Company, complete with camels, the company mascot, in the structure's spandrel panels.  There'll be an open bar, a silent auction, juggling, magic, jazz tunes, and Revolution brew.  Plus I'm seeing a big finale of a herd of roller-skating camels bearing popcorn and bobby pins, but now I'm thinking that may just be the after-effects of the fish I had for dinner, which may have been past it's prime.  In any event, you can get more information and purchase tickets on-line.

We're now closing in on 80 great events on the September calendar.  Check out all the details here.

Finally, we've learned of still another exhibition in what's becoming the season of Bertrand Goldberg, with The Arts Club of Chicago opening Bertrand Goldberg:Reflections to the pubic on September 16th, which . . . 
. . . examines the sources of and influences on Goldberg’s vision by looking at his personal collection of art and artifacts, his friendships with artists and intellectuals, his personal photographs, and his designs for furniture, jewelry, and functional fabrications, to provide an understanding of the man behind the public image. Unlike many architects, Goldberg did not keep a sketchbook, preferring to solve problems directly. Goldberg’s many layered solutions seem to come organically from the objects that he chose to surround himself with: works by fellow Bauhaus-associated artists Paul Klee and Max Bill, Italian artist Pietro Consagra, and his teacher Josef Albers; cultural artifacts; and sculpture and string constructions from his mother-in-law, abstract/constructivist artist Lillian Florsheim. The Arts Club’s exhibition is a rare glimpse into the “studio” of one of the most innovative architects of the 20th century.
The exhibition will run until January 13th of next year.

Monday, September 05, 2011

Tigerman, Goldberg, Botta, Cobb, Simonds, Jahn, Sobek, Pecha Kucha 19, and a billion more - it's the September calendar!

 So what's the deal about Labor Day that turns on the chill of Fall as if by switch? I don't like the end of summer, but I'm consoled by the fact that the pace of the September Calendar of Chicago Architectural Events has exploded like a Coke bottle full of Mentos, with over seventy great items and counting.

And not even in that tally, there's the long-awaiting blockbuster exhibition at the Art Institute, Bertrand Goldberg: Architecture of Invention, plus a companion show, Inside Marina City: A Project by Iker Gil and E.G. Larsson, while the ArchiTech Gallery chimes in with Architectural drawing: from Wright to Goldberg. And then, mid-month, Chicago gets another new museum building with the opening of Depaul Art Museum's new home on Fullerton.

This week starts out with a bang with edition 19 of Pecha Kucha, at Martyr's, on Tuesday the 6th, while over at the Gene Siskel, a new series Designs for Living: The Apartment Genre, kicks off with a last showing of Alfred Hitchcock's Rear Window, perhaps the most perverse study of the dynamics of life, exhibited and observed, in the adjacent compartmentalized boxes of a big city.

On Thursday the 8th, Patrick Blanc talks about Vertical Gardens at the Alliance Francise, while on Friday the 9th at the of U of C Law School, Stanley Tigerman kicks off the Frank Lloyd Wright Preservation Trust's new series, Thinking into the  Future: The Robie House Series on Architecture, Design and Ideas.

On Wednesday, the 14th, Robin Rhodes lectures on Transition and Transformation in Greek Architecture at the Driehaus Museum, aka the Nickerson Mansion, while on Friday, the 15th, Rolf Achilles talks about Art Nouveau Book Art Design at the Second Presbyterian Church.  The School of Architecture at IIT jump starts its fall lecture series on Friday, September 16th with a superstar constellation of Werner Sobek, Manfred Hegger, and Helmut Jahn lecturing on High-Rises for the Future: Sustainability, Architecture and Engineering Perspectives.  Also at IIT, Dan Rockhill talks about his current work on September 28th, and Barbara Geiger talks about her new book on Landscape Gardener O.C. Simonds on Thursday, the 21st.  Elsewhere on the new book front, Edward Wolner discusses and signs copies of his new work, Henry Ives Cobb's Chicago, at the Glessner House Museum on Tuesday, the 20th.

Want more?  How about a three-day symposium, Seaside at 30: Lessons from the First New Urbanist Community, starting on Thursday the 29th at the School of Architecture at Notre Dame, with such luminaries as Léon Krier, Andrés Duany, Elizabeth Plater-Zyberk. (will there be a surprise appearance by Jim Carey?) On Wednesday, the 28th, there's an all-day symposium on the 175th anniversary of Clarke House, and a two-day Great Cities/Ordinary Lives conference at UIC on the 16th and 17th.

Preservation Chicago's fall fundraiser?  AIA Chicago tours of Zoka Zola's Studio and the Lincoln Park Nature Boardwalk, and a discussion by Sheri L. Carter of the use of terra cotta at Mario Botta's Bechtler Museum? Geoffrey Baer? Dale Greenwood Green on Historic African-American Religious Architecture at Quinn Chapel AME Church?  A preview at CAF of it's extraordinary October event: openhousechicago: Chicago's Hidden Gems?  I could go on and on, but rather than reading about it twice, check out the nearly 80 items on the September Calendar of Chicago Architectural Events.

for Labor Day: The Architecture of Chicago's Unionville

(from 2010): Chicago has always been a strong union town. The story's told that it was a wildcat bricklayer's strike that sent William Le Baron Jenney home so early one day that his shocked wife absent-mindedly parked the heavy book she was reading atop a birdcage. The major saw the weighty volume supported on that minimal skeleton of thin metal, and - voila! - the idea of the steel frame skyscraper was born. (When the legend becomes fact, print the legend . . . )

In the early decades of the last century, a section of the West side north of Jackson and on either side of Ashland became home to a large number of union . . . (read the rest and see all the photo's, here.)

Thursday, September 01, 2011

Today: Landmarks 2011 Preservation Excellence Awards, Okrent's Chicago from the Sky

As usual, we're working to complete the September calendar (and it's packed), with the month really starting after the Labor Day holiday.

Two Thursday events day, however, kick off the month.  Today at 10:00 a.m., at the Sidney Yates Room at the Cultural Center, the Commission on Chicago Landmarks will hold the Awards Ceremony for its 2011 Preservation Excellence Awards, with the honorees including both a book, The Complete Architecture of Adler & Sullivan; an exhibition, Louis Sullivan's Idea, and such renovation projects as the White Castle #16 on Cermak, Jens Jensen's 300 West Adams, the McCormick Double House on Rush, among others.  The usual monthly meeting of the commission, Prentice still not included, takes place at 12:45 in City Hall chambers.

Also at the Cultural Center, at 12:15 in the Millennium Room, Friends of Downtown's September session will feature urban planning consultant and photographer Lawrence Okrent discussing and showing images from his book, Chicago From the Sky: A Region Transformed.


Tuesday, August 30, 2011

Sunday, August 28, 2011

How to Build a Great City for under $350 million, or Cleopatra conquers the Roman Forum in 70mm spectacle, by way of Seattle

click images for larger view
If you haven't seen a film in 70mm, even if you've taken in  various IMAX productions, you've probably never seen film at its highest point of visual spectacle.  A stunning detail of image, coupled to a huge screen and the kind of production budgets only Hollywood can provide created a series of spectacles that remain unrivaled, even against the best that the current state of CGI can provide. Just the names, names like Ben-Hur, Spartacus and Lawrence of Arabia evoke the very idea of epic spectacle.

VHS, DVD, and now streaming video largely killed off the revival houses that used to screen vintage films.  Showings of motion pictures in their original 70mm format are especially rare as few theaters today are equipped with the necessary projectors.  At the present time in Chicago, only the Music Box appears equipped to screen 70mm.

So a festival of 70mm films is a big deal.  Just last week, the Paramount in Austin, Texas held a mini-festival of 70mm, but at end of September/beginning of October, things will go epic at Seattle's Cinerama Theater's Big Screen 70mm Film Festival, with showings over three weeks of  more than a dozen 70mm films, including, Lawrence, 2001, My Fair Lady, Baraka and Tron.  Like the Cinerama Dome in Hollywood, Seattle's 800-seat Cinerama opened in 1963.  It hadn't showed a 70mm production in almost three decades and was in grave danger of destruction when Microsoft co-founder Paul Allen bought it for $3 million, and spent millions more restoring it to its original glory.
Unlike the old movie palaces, which were either converted vaudeville theaters, or custom-built in the 1920's silent days to accomodate major stage shows, usually in some takeoff of classical styles, whether Baroque, Mayan, or Roman, theaters like the Seattle Cinerama, designed by architect Raymond H. Peck, were built specifically and exclusively for film.  Their high-tech, modernist design reflected the state-of-the-art status of the sound and projection.
 In Chicago, after showman Michael Todd bought the "legitimate" Harris Theatre, designed by architect C. Howard Crane, he enlisted talents such as Bertrand Goldberg and artist Joseph Albers to transform it into a glamorous showplace of contemporary design that he then named after himself.  After Todd died in a 1958 plane crash, the Michael Todd theatre, as well as the Cinestage just next door, remained owned by his widow, Elizabeth Taylor, until she discovered many years later that they had descended into showing soft-core porn.

Getting back to the roster for the Seattle festival, there's also Jacque Tati's amazing Playtime, where the 70mm format is used to explicate variations on an epic scale on the absurdities of modernism in general and modernist architecture in particular, and Richard Brook's film version of Conrad's Lord Jim, with Peter O'Toole in the title role.  Besides Lady, musicals range from West Side Story, to Chitty Chitty Bang Bang to South Pacific, along with another film that was enormously popular in its time but largely forgotten today, Those Magnificent Men in Their Flying Machines.

The Sound of Music, which will also be screened, was the high water mark of roadshow exhibition.  In city after city, its run was counted not in months but in years, as the picture went on to dethrone Gone With the Wind as the biggest grossing film of all time.  Today, the film's sugary nature - one critic remarked that it could not be endured within a dose of insulin - makes this seem inexplicable, and the studio interiors only add to the dullness. But in 70mm, you can see how the location shooting in Austria created images of richness and often stunning beauty.
Almost finally, there will be showings of the original Cinerama production, This is Cinerama, and one of  only two narrative films to be shot in that process, How the West was Won.  Cinerama films, as explained in this great post on the Harry Helms blog, were actually 35mm, but times three.  A special camera shot three separate strips of film, center, left and right, which were projected in exact synchronization on a single, massive curving screen.
 The move to narrative films also sounded the death knell for true Cinerama.  Beginning with 1963's It's a Mad, Mad, Mad,Mad World,  "Cinerama" became a single ultra-wide 70mm print projected with a special lens onto the curving Cinerama screen.

Like IMAX today, the 70mm roadshow production was a clever ploy to enhance revenue by charging ticket prices substantially higher than that for standard releases.  In the mid-1960's, a midweek evening ticket for a roadshow film might go for $2.80, versus about $1.85 for a regular release at the United Arists or Oriental. At one time the Michael Todd and Cinestage (whose facades survive in front of the new Goodman Theater), the McVickers (demolished), and Palace all showed roadshow films, with theaters such as the Loop and Esquire also going along for the ride at times.  You can read more about the rise and fall of the roadshow in our previous piece  here.
Lawrence and My Fair Lady get occasional revivals, but the real rarity in Seattle will be sceenings of 70mm prints of 1963's Cleopatra, with Elizabeth Taylor, Richard Burton and Rex Harrison.  Costing over $300,000,000 in today's money, it still holds the title as the most expensive film ever made.  Taylor's serious illness had already set the production off the rails, and the studio brought on writer/director Joseph L. Mankiewicz to take over the production of a film that was already $5 million over budget.  The revised script was only half finished when filming restarted, with Mankiewicz, like David Selnick before him, turning to pharmaceutical reinforcement to allow him to write through the night the pages we would shoot the next day.

While the final result bears shows the literary hallmarks of the man who wrote such witty films as All About Eve, Cleopatra was not a critical success.  It was the highest-grossing film of 1963, but that was still not enough to cover costs.  In Chicago, it played not at one of the usual road-show houses, but at the State-Lake (now the ABC7 studios), which had a larger seating capacity to take advantage of the public's heavy-breathing, if short-lived interest in the tabloid details of Taylor's and Burton's love life.
A good bit of coherence was lost when Fox spurned Mankiewicz's suggestion to release the film as an six-hour epic shown in two parts, as the Russian War and Peace would be in the next decade.  Instead, Cleopatra was released clocking in at a still posterior-challenging four+ hours, and then cut again to closer to three for general release.

Still, Cleopatra remains a literate, often witty film.  It doesn't scrimp on the spectacle, and its climatic sequence of Cleopatra's entrance into the Imperial Forum,  demonstrating what the Romans might have achieved if only they had had Fox production head Spyros Skouros to write the checks to cover the overruns, remains one of the most spectacular sequences in cinema.

Of course, watching Cleopatra on You Tube is like viewing Guernica on a dinner plate

Seattle's Big Screen 70mm Film Festival takes place September 30th through October 16th, and includes no fewer than 43 scheduled screenings.   Five of those screenings are still listed as "TBA",  so is there hope for the additional a Spartacus or a Ben-Hur?  Check out all the information on the festival here.

The Birds and the BeeInsect

 click images for larger view